Chaikin Trial Group secured a $3,600,000 settlement for a self-employed business owner in his 60s whose car was rear-ended by a commercial box truck while he was stopped at a red light in Manhattan. After winning summary judgment on liability, our team answered the defense’s claim that his injuries were age-related and pre-existing, and prepared the case for trial. The defense had once offered $500,000. The case settled in January 2026 for more than seven times that amount.
Case at a Glance
- Settlement Amount: $3,600,000 (Gross)
- Case Type: Truck Accident — Rear-End Collision
- Incident Date: September 28, 2022
- Location: Manhattan (New York County), NY
- Client: Self-employed business owner, age 60 at the time of the crash
- Attorneys: Ian M. Chaikin, Esq. and Mehmet Gokce, Esq.
- Status: Settled — Case Closed
How the Accident Happened
At about 9:30 a.m. on September 28, 2022, our client was stopped at a red light on 10th Avenue at 51st Street in Manhattan when a box truck making deliveries for a food distribution company slammed into the back of his car.
He was doing exactly what the law requires: waiting for the light. Under New York Vehicle and Traffic Law §1129, a driver may not follow another vehicle more closely than is reasonable and prudent, and must leave enough room to stop. A truck that strikes a car stopped at a red light has failed to do that.
The truck driver admitted as much. In the company’s own incident report, he wrote that he rear-ended our client’s vehicle while it was stopped at a red light. Photographs of our client’s car showed significant damage to the rear of the vehicle.
Injuries Sustained
In the months and years after the crash, our client needed treatment for his ankle, shoulder and spine, including three surgeries:
- Left ankle arthroscopy with debridement and a modified Broström repair of the torn lateral ankle ligaments, reinforced with a tissue graft (June 9, 2023)
- Left shoulder arthroscopy with repair of a torn subscapularis rotator cuff tendon, biceps tenodesis, subacromial decompression, and debridement of the labrum and a partial supraspinatus tear (November 8, 2023)
- Three-level anterior cervical discectomy and fusion (ACDF) at C4–C5, C5–C6 and C6–C7, with interbody implants and an anterior plate and screws (June 27, 2024)
- Disc herniations in the lower back at L4–L5 and L5–S1 and in the upper back at T1–T2, shown on MRI
A three-level neck fusion is a major, permanent operation, and together with his other surgeries it changed how our client works and lives.
How Chaikin Trial Group Won
Winning Summary Judgment on Liability
Chaikin Trial Group filed suit in New York County Supreme Court and moved for summary judgment on liability in May 2023. On November 16, 2023, the court granted the motion in its entirety, finding that our client had been rear-ended while stopped at a red traffic signal and that the defense offered no non-negligent explanation for the crash. That took fault off the table and let the case focus on our client’s injuries.
Defeating the “Pre-Existing Condition” Defense
The defense argued that our client’s injuries were degenerative and age-related, that they existed before the crash, and that the impact did not cause them. This is one of the most common defenses raised against older accident victims. Our team answered it with his treating physicians’ records, his imaging studies, and the timeline of his surgeries after the crash. When the defense also tried to force open his unrelated medical history, our team defeated that effort, and the court held he did not have to turn over records for body parts that were not part of his claim. Under New York law, a defendant is responsible for injuries it causes or makes worse, even if the injured person was not in perfect health beforehand.
Preparing for Trial and Reaching the Excess Coverage
The case went to mediation in 2025 without resolving. Our team kept preparing the case for trial, documenting his lost business income and future medical needs. The defense had once offered $500,000. In January 2026 the case settled for $3,600,000, with multiple insurers contributing.
What This Settlement Means for Rear-End Crash Victims in New York
Insurers often treat injured people in their 50s and 60s as easy targets, blaming every injury on age and wear and tear. This result shows that a well-documented case, built on treating-physician evidence, imaging and a clear medical timeline, can overcome that defense. It also shows why it pays to reject a low offer when the evidence supports far more, and to push a case past the primary policy limit when the injuries call for it.
If you were hurt when a truck or car struck you from behind anywhere in New York, Contact Chaikin Trial Group today for a free case evaluation.
Damages Available in Truck Accident Cases
- Past and future medical expenses, including surgery
- Lost income and loss of business earnings
- Pain and suffering
- Aggravation of pre-existing conditions
- Permanent loss of use or limitation of a body part
- Loss of enjoyment of life
Other Accident Results by Chaikin Trial Group
Our attorneys have secured significant results for injured New Yorkers across the five boroughs and Long Island:
- $6,100,000 — Limousine accident, DWI truck driver
- $8,000,000 — Construction accident, falling object from height
- $5,475,000 — Queens construction accident, floor collapse
View Our Full Verdicts & Settlements Page
Related Resources & Information
Practice Areas
- New York Truck Accident Lawyer: https://www.chaikintrialgroup.com/new-york/truck-accident-lawyer/
- Manhattan Truck Accident Lawyer: https://www.chaikintrialgroup.com/manhattan-ny/truck-accident-lawyer/
- Manhattan Car Accident Lawyer: https://www.chaikintrialgroup.com/manhattan-ny/car-accident-lawyer/
- New York Car Accident Lawyer: https://www.chaikintrialgroup.com/new-york/car-accident-lawyer/
- Manhattan Personal Injury Lawyer: https://www.chaikintrialgroup.com/manhattan-ny/personal-injury-lawyer/
Truck Accident FAQs
- Can I Recover Compensation If the Accident Aggravated a Pre-Existing Medical Condition? https://www.chaikintrialgroup.com/faqs/can-i-recover-compensation-if-the-accident-aggravated-a-pre-existing-medical-condition/
- How Much Can I Get from a Truck Accident Claim in New York? https://www.chaikintrialgroup.com/faqs/how-much-can-i-get-from-a-truck-accident-claim-in-new-york/
- Can I Sue Both the Trucking Company and the Driver After an Accident? https://www.chaikintrialgroup.com/faqs/can-i-sue-both-the-trucking-company-and-the-driver-after-an-accident/
- What Should I Do If the Insurance Company Offers Me an Immediate Quick Settlement? https://www.chaikintrialgroup.com/faqs/what-should-i-do-if-the-insurance-company-offers-me-a-quick-settlement/
About Chaikin Trial Group
Chaikin Trial Group is a New York personal injury law firm with over 50 years of combined legal experience. Founded by Ian M. Chaikin, Esq., the firm represents injured workers and accident victims throughout New York City, Long Island, the five boroughs, and beyond. The firm has recovered more than $100 million in damages for clients.
- About Ian Chaikin: https://www.chaikintrialgroup.com/the-firm/ian-chaikin/
- Full Verdicts & Settlements: https://www.chaikintrialgroup.com/results/
- More Case Results: https://www.chaikintrialgroup.com/more-case-results/
- Free Case Evaluation: https://www.chaikintrialgroup.com/contact-us/