Chaikin Trial Group secured a $1,750,000 settlement for a woman who was standing at the counter of a Brooklyn restaurant, placing her order, when the ceiling above her collapsed onto her head. Sworn testimony showed the ceiling had leaked every time it rained for years. Her injuries led to a cervical spinal fusion and lumbar spine surgery, and the case settled after we moved for summary judgment on liability.
Case at a Glance
- Settlement Amount: $1,750,000 (Gross)
- Case Type: Premises Liability — Ceiling Collapse
- Incident Date: June 1, 2018
- Location: Brooklyn (Kings County), NY
- Client: A restaurant customer
- Attorneys: Ian M. Chaikin, Esq. and Mehmet Gokce, Esq.
- Status: Settled — Case Closed
How the Accident Happened
On the morning of June 1, 2018, our client walked into a restaurant in Brooklyn and stepped up to the counter to order. She saw no sign of a leak or damage overhead. As she placed her order, the dropped ceiling above the counter gave way and came down on her head.
The collapse was no accident of chance. The restaurant’s operator later testified that the ceiling above the counter leaked whenever it rained, and had for years. Water soaked the ceiling tiles until they were broken and rotten. He replaced tiles several times, and during stretches of heavy rain he left wet tiles in place because new ones would be soaked again within minutes. He also testified that he had complained about the leaks to the building’s ownership.
A landowner in New York has a duty to keep its property in reasonably safe condition. When an owner knows a roof or ceiling leaks and does not fix it, a collapse onto a customer is exactly the harm that duty exists to prevent.
Injuries Sustained
The falling ceiling caused serious injuries to our client’s neck and back:
- Anterior cervical fusion at C4-C5 with partial removal of the C4 and C5 vertebrae and decompression of the spinal cord and nerve roots (October 2019)
- Decompressive lumbar laminectomies with facetectomies and foraminotomies at L4, L5 and S1 for disc herniations with severe radiculopathy (September 2021)
- Cervical disc herniation with radiculopathy affecting the arms and hands
- Cervical spine injection
- Injuries to both shoulders
- Post-traumatic headaches
Her doctors described the injuries as permanent, with a risk of further surgery.
How Chaikin Trial Group Won
Bringing the Right Parties Into the Case
The building had several layers of ownership and management, and the restaurant operated as a tenant. We sued the property owner and the restaurant operators, then obtained a court order allowing us to amend the complaint and add the building’s management company. That made sure every party with responsibility for the ceiling had to answer for it.
Turning the Defense Witnesses Into Our Best Evidence
We deposed the restaurant’s operator and the building owner’s representative. The operator described years of leaks over the counter, water-damaged tiles he had replaced himself, and complaints he made to the building’s ownership. The owner’s representative could not contradict that account, and the lease placed responsibility for maintaining the building on the owner. Using that testimony, we moved for summary judgment on liability, arguing that the defendants had actual notice of the dangerous condition.
Building the Damages Case
We documented each stage of our client’s treatment, serving supplemental bills of particulars as she underwent a neck fusion and later lumbar surgery. Facing that record, two insurance carriers for the defendants both contributed, and the case settled for $1,750,000 in May 2024.
What This Settlement Means for Premises Liability Victims in New York
Customers have every right to expect that the ceiling of a store or restaurant will stay where it belongs. When a building has a known, long-running leak, the owner and the businesses inside cannot simply swap out stained tiles and hope for the best. The key evidence in cases like this often comes from the defendants’ own employees, which is why thorough depositions matter.
If you were injured by a falling ceiling or another dangerous condition in a store, restaurant or apartment building in Brooklyn or anywhere in New York, contact Chaikin Trial Group today for a free case evaluation.
Damages Available in Premises Liability Cases
- Past and future medical expenses, including surgery and rehabilitation
- Lost wages and loss of future earning capacity
- Past and future pain and suffering
- Loss of enjoyment of life
- Costs of future care and treatment
Other Premises Liability Results by Chaikin Trial Group
Our attorneys have secured significant results for injured New Yorkers across the five boroughs and Long Island:
- $1,750,000 — Bronx ceiling collapse
- $1,650,000 — Bronx shower ceiling collapse
- $1,450,000 — Manhattan sidewalk trip and fall
- $3,175,000 — Manhattan labor law, falling object
View Our Full Verdicts & Settlements Page
Related Resources & Information
Practice Areas
- Brooklyn Premises Liability Lawyer: https://www.chaikintrialgroup.com/brooklyn-ny/premises-liability-lawyer/
- Brooklyn Personal Injury Lawyer: https://www.chaikintrialgroup.com/brooklyn-ny/personal-injury-lawyer/
- Manhattan Spinal Cord Injury Lawyer: https://www.chaikintrialgroup.com/manhattan-ny/spinal-cord-injury-lawyer/
- New York Personal Injury Lawyer: https://www.chaikintrialgroup.com/new-york-ny/personal-injury-lawyer/
Premises Liability FAQs
- Injured in an apartment ceiling collapse? New Yorkers, read this. https://www.chaikintrialgroup.com/faqs/injured-in-an-apartment-ceiling-collapse-new-yorkers-read-this/
- Can I recover compensation if the accident aggravated a pre-existing medical condition? https://www.chaikintrialgroup.com/faqs/can-i-recover-compensation-if-the-accident-aggravated-a-pre-existing-medical-condition/
- What should I do if the insurance company offers me a quick settlement? https://www.chaikintrialgroup.com/faqs/what-should-i-do-if-the-insurance-company-offers-me-a-quick-settlement/
- Are personal injury settlement payouts taxable in New York? https://www.chaikintrialgroup.com/faqs/are-personal-injury-or-wrongful-death-settlement-payouts-taxable-in-new-york/
About Chaikin Trial Group
Chaikin Trial Group is a New York personal injury law firm with over 50 years of combined legal experience. Founded by Ian M. Chaikin, Esq., the firm represents injured workers and accident victims throughout New York City, Long Island, the five boroughs, and beyond. The firm has recovered more than $100 million in damages for clients.
- About Ian Chaikin: https://www.chaikintrialgroup.com/the-firm/ian-chaikin/
- Full Verdicts & Settlements: https://www.chaikintrialgroup.com/results/
- More Case Results: https://www.chaikintrialgroup.com/more-case-results/
- Free Case Evaluation: https://www.chaikintrialgroup.com/contact-us/