Chaikin Trial Group secured a $1,650,000 settlement for a 54-year-old Bronx woman whose bathroom ceiling collapsed on her while she was taking a shower. The collapse followed an ongoing leak from the bathroom upstairs, and her injuries led to five surgeries. Chaikin Trial Group resolved the case in May 2025, before the defendants were even deposed, for roughly 82% of all available insurance coverage.
Case at a Glance
- Settlement Amount: $1,650,000 (Gross)
- Case Type: Premises Liability — Apartment Ceiling Collapse
- Incident Date: May 24, 2022
- Location: Bronx, NY
- Client: 54-year-old woman
- Attorneys: Ian M. Chaikin, Esq. and Mehmet Gokce
- Status: Settled — Case Closed
How the Accident Happened
On May 24, 2022, our client was taking a shower in her Bronx apartment when the bathroom ceiling collapsed on her.
The collapse did not come out of nowhere. Water had been leaking from the bathroom in the apartment upstairs for some time, and our client says she reported the leak to the building’s superintendent several times. The leak was repaired only after the ceiling came down.
Under New York’s Multiple Dwelling Law §78, the owner of an apartment building must keep it in good repair. A leak that is reported again and again, and left unfixed until a ceiling falls on a tenant, is a failure of that basic duty.
Injuries Sustained
Our client’s injuries affected her neck, lower back, shoulder and both knees. Over the following two years she underwent five surgeries:
- Left shoulder arthroscopy to treat a torn biceps tendon, an anterior labral tear and a cartilage injury, with synovectomy, bursectomy and release of adhesions (September 21, 2022)
- Two-level anterior cervical discectomy and fusion at C4–C5 and C5–C6 for disc herniations, with interbody cages (November 30, 2022)
- Right knee arthroscopy with partial medial and lateral meniscectomies for torn menisci and removal of loose bodies (May 15, 2024)
- Left knee arthroscopy with partial medial and lateral meniscectomies for torn menisci (June 19, 2024)
- L5–S1 lumbar fusion with discectomy, an interbody device and segmental fixation, for a disc herniation with instability and severe foraminal stenosis (September 30, 2024)
She also missed weeks of work while she recovered. Two spinal fusions and three joint surgeries, spread over more than two years, show how far the harm from one collapsed ceiling can reach. Each procedure meant more time in recovery, more physical therapy and more disruption to her daily life.
How Chaikin Trial Group Won
Establishing Notice of the Leak
In a ceiling-collapse case, the central question is usually whether the building knew about the problem in time to fix it. Here, our client had reported the leak to the superintendent several times, and the repair came only after the collapse. Chaikin Trial Group filed suit in Bronx Supreme Court and built the case around that history of complaints.
Documenting Every Surgery
Our client’s treatment did not stop with one operation. As her care progressed from the shoulder to the cervical spine, both knees and finally the lumbar spine, Chaikin Trial Group kept the damages case current, so that each new surgery was part of the record the defense had to answer.
Recovering Most of the Available Coverage
The defendants had $1 million in primary coverage and $1 million in excess coverage, $2 million in all. In April 2025 the defense offered $500,000, then raised its offer to $1 million. Mehmet Gokce kept negotiating, and in May 2025 the case settled for $1,650,000, before the defendants’ deposition was even held.
Settling at that stage was a deliberate choice. A defendant’s deposition, further discovery and a trial date can each add months to a case. Resolving it when the defense was ready to pay most of its coverage gave our client a strong recovery without that wait.
That result captured roughly 82% of all available coverage and spared our client another one to two years of litigation. For a client recovering from five surgeries, a strong result now was worth more than a longer fight over the remaining policy limits.
What This Settlement Means for Tenants in New York
A leak that a tenant reports and a building ignores is not a minor maintenance issue. It is a warning. When a building owner fails to act on repeated complaints and a ceiling collapses, the owner can be held responsible for every injury that follows, including surgeries that unfold over years.
If a leak or ceiling collapse in your apartment injured you, keep a record of every complaint, photograph the damage and follow through on your medical care. Contact Chaikin Trial Group today for a free case evaluation.
Damages Available in Ceiling Collapse Cases
- Past and future medical expenses, including surgery
- Lost wages and diminished earning capacity
- Pain and suffering
- Permanent physical limitations
- Loss of enjoyment of life
Other Personal Injury Results by Chaikin Trial Group
Our attorneys have secured significant outcomes for injured New Yorkers throughout New York City and Long Island:
- $8,000,000 — Construction accident, falling object from height
- $6,100,000 — Limousine accident, DWI truck driver
- $5,475,000 — Queens construction accident, floor collapse
View Our Full Verdicts & Settlements Page
Related Resources & Information
Practice Areas
- Bronx Premises Liability Lawyer: https://www.chaikintrialgroup.com/bronx-ny/premises-liability-lawyer/
- Bronx Personal Injury Lawyer: https://www.chaikintrialgroup.com/bronx-ny/personal-injury-lawyer/
- Ceiling Collapse Lawyer (Long Island): https://www.chaikintrialgroup.com/long-island-ny/premises-liability-lawyer/ceiling-collapse/
- Manhattan Premises Liability Lawyer: https://www.chaikintrialgroup.com/manhattan-ny/premises-liability-lawyer/
Ceiling Collapse FAQs
- Injured in an Apartment Ceiling Collapse? New Yorkers, Read This: https://www.chaikintrialgroup.com/faqs/injured-in-an-apartment-ceiling-collapse-new-yorkers-read-this/
- How Long Do I Have to File a Personal Injury Claim in NY? https://www.chaikintrialgroup.com/faqs/how-long-do-i-have-to-file-a-personal-injury-claim-in-ny/
- What Should I Do If the Insurance Company Offers Me an Immediate Quick Settlement? https://www.chaikintrialgroup.com/faqs/what-should-i-do-if-the-insurance-company-offers-me-a-quick-settlement/
- Will I Have to Reimburse My Health Insurance or Medicare Out of My Injury Settlement? https://www.chaikintrialgroup.com/faqs/will-i-have-to-reimburse-my-health-insurance-or-medicare-out-of-my-injury-settlement/
About Chaikin Trial Group
Chaikin Trial Group is a New York personal injury law firm with over 50 years of combined legal experience. Founded by Ian M. Chaikin, Esq., the firm represents injured workers and accident victims throughout New York City, Long Island, the five boroughs, and beyond. The firm has recovered more than $100 million in damages for clients.
- About Ian Chaikin: https://www.chaikintrialgroup.com/the-firm/ian-chaikin/
- Full Verdicts & Settlements: https://www.chaikintrialgroup.com/results/
- More Case Results: https://www.chaikintrialgroup.com/more-case-results/
- Free Case Evaluation: https://www.chaikintrialgroup.com/contact-us/