# $1,300,000 Labor Law Settlement | Manhattan Steel Beam, No Hoist

[Chaikin Trial Group](https://www.chaikintrialgroup.com/) secured a $1,300,000 settlement for a construction worker injured while carrying a steel I-beam by hand on a Manhattan rooftop. No hoist or rigging was provided, and he slipped on debris while the beam was in the air.

## Case at a Glance

- Settlement Amount: $1,300,000 (Gross)
- Case Type: Labor Law / Construction Accident
- Incident Date: September 2, 2010
- Location: Manhattan (New York County), NY
- Client: A construction worker
- Attorney: [Ian M. Chaikin, Esq.](https://www.chaikintrialgroup.com/the-firm/ian-chaikin/)
- Status: Settled — Case Closed

## How the Accident Happened

On September 2, 2010, our client was working on the roof of a building on Lexington Avenue in Manhattan. He and a coworker were told to move steel I-beams, weighing about 500 pounds, to a new spot on the roof.

No hoist, rig or other device was provided. The two men lifted each beam by hand to about three and a half feet off the roof. While carrying a beam, our client slipped on debris on the roof, and the beam came down rapidly.

[New York Labor Law §240(1)](https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/laws/LAB/240) requires owners and contractors to give workers proper devices when they must hoist or secure heavy loads. [Labor Law §241(6)](https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/laws/LAB/241) and the Industrial Code also require work areas to be kept free of debris that can cause slips.

## Injuries Sustained

Our client suffered serious neck and back injuries. His treatment included:

- Disc herniations at C5–C6 and C6–C7 with nerve-root dysfunction in both arms
- Anterior cervical discectomy and fusion at C5–C6 and C6–C7, with partial corpectomies and plate-and-screw instrumentation (January 2012)
- A trial spinal cord stimulator implant for chronic neck pain and post-traumatic headaches (September 2014)
- Lumbar disc bulges at L2–L3, L3–L4 and L4–L5

He was left with chronic neck pain and headaches.

## How Chaikin Trial Group Won

### Building the Labor Law Case

We sued the building owner, the construction manager and other contractors in Supreme Court, New York County, under Labor Law §§240(1) and 241(6). The undisputed facts were powerful: a 500-pound beam was being carried by hand above the roof, and no hoisting device was provided.

### Defeating the Defense’s Arguments

The defense argued that the slip, not the weight of the beam, caused the accident, and that our client’s descriptions of the debris were inconsistent. We showed that the roof was covered in debris and garbage unrelated to his work, and that the lack of a proper device was a proximate cause of the injury.

### Resolving the Case Before Trial

With trial approaching, the defendants and their insurers agreed to pay a total of $1,300,000.

## What This Settlement Means for Construction Workers in New York

New York’s Labor Law protects workers who are forced to move heavy loads without proper equipment. When contractors save time by skipping a hoist, they can be held responsible when a worker is hurt.

If you were hurt lifting, hoisting or carrying materials on a job site, you may have a claim against the owner and contractors in addition to workers’ compensation. [Contact Chaikin Trial Group today for a free case evaluation.](https://www.chaikintrialgroup.com/contact-us/)

### Damages Available in Labor Law Cases

- Past and future medical expenses
- Lost wages and loss of earning capacity
- Pain and suffering
- Loss of enjoyment of life
- Future medical care

## Other Labor Law Results by Chaikin Trial Group

Chaikin Trial Group has recovered major Labor Law results for injured workers:

- [$8,000,000 — Construction accident, falling object from height](https://www.chaikintrialgroup.com/8000000-settlement/)
- [$5,475,000 — Queens construction accident, floor collapse](https://www.chaikintrialgroup.com/results/5475000-queens-construction-accident-floor-collapse/)
- [$3,175,000 — Manhattan Labor Law, falling object on stairs](https://www.chaikintrialgroup.com/results/3175000-manhattan-labor-law-falling-object-stairs/)

View Our Full [Verdicts & Settlements Page](https://www.chaikintrialgroup.com/results/)

## Related Resources & Information

### Practice Areas

- Manhattan Construction Accident Lawyer: [https://www.chaikintrialgroup.com/manhattan-ny/work-injury-lawyer/construction/](https://www.chaikintrialgroup.com/manhattan-ny/work-injury-lawyer/construction/)
- New York Construction Accident Lawyer: [https://www.chaikintrialgroup.com/new-york/work-injury-lawyer/construction/](https://www.chaikintrialgroup.com/new-york/work-injury-lawyer/construction/)
- Manhattan Work Injury Lawyer: [https://www.chaikintrialgroup.com/manhattan-ny/work-injury-lawyer/](https://www.chaikintrialgroup.com/manhattan-ny/work-injury-lawyer/)
- Manhattan Equipment Injury Lawyer: [https://www.chaikintrialgroup.com/manhattan-ny/work-injury-lawyer/equipment-injury/](https://www.chaikintrialgroup.com/manhattan-ny/work-injury-lawyer/equipment-injury/)
- Manhattan Catastrophic Injury Lawyer: [https://www.chaikintrialgroup.com/manhattan-ny/catastrophic-injury-lawyer/](https://www.chaikintrialgroup.com/manhattan-ny/catastrophic-injury-lawyer/)

### Labor Law FAQs

- What is New York’s Scaffold Law (Labor Law § 240/241)? [https://www.chaikintrialgroup.com/faqs/what-is-new-yorks-scaffold-law-labor-law-240-241/](https://www.chaikintrialgroup.com/faqs/what-is-new-yorks-scaffold-law-labor-law-240-241/)
- What compensation can I get for a construction work injury in NY? [https://www.chaikintrialgroup.com/faqs/what-compensation-can-i-get-for-a-construction-work-injury-in-ny/](https://www.chaikintrialgroup.com/faqs/what-compensation-can-i-get-for-a-construction-work-injury-in-ny/)
- Do I need a lawyer after a construction site injury in NY? [https://www.chaikintrialgroup.com/faqs/do-i-need-a-lawyer-after-a-construction-site-injury-in-ny/](https://www.chaikintrialgroup.com/faqs/do-i-need-a-lawyer-after-a-construction-site-injury-in-ny/)
- Can I sue my employer for a work injury in New York? [https://www.chaikintrialgroup.com/faqs/can-i-sue-my-employer-for-a-work-injury-in-new-york/](https://www.chaikintrialgroup.com/faqs/can-i-sue-my-employer-for-a-work-injury-in-new-york/)

## About Chaikin Trial Group

Chaikin Trial Group is a New York personal injury law firm with over 50 years of combined legal experience. Founded by Ian M. Chaikin, Esq., the firm represents injured workers and accident victims throughout New York City, Long Island, the five boroughs, and beyond. The firm has recovered more than $100 million in damages for clients.

- About Ian Chaikin: [https://www.chaikintrialgroup.com/the-firm/ian-chaikin/](https://www.chaikintrialgroup.com/the-firm/ian-chaikin/)
- Full Verdicts & Settlements: [https://www.chaikintrialgroup.com/results/](https://www.chaikintrialgroup.com/results/)
- More Case Results: [https://www.chaikintrialgroup.com/more-case-results/](https://www.chaikintrialgroup.com/more-case-results/)
- Free Case Evaluation: [https://www.chaikintrialgroup.com/contact-us/](https://www.chaikintrialgroup.com/contact-us/)

---

Source: https://www.chaikintrialgroup.com/results/1300000-manhattan-labor-law-steel-beam/
